2 Synod Solution Annex
Welcome!

Revisiting the "New Synod" concept by the Presbyterians for Renewal, as presented as an overture by Santa Barbara Presbytery (2010):


 New Synod

G-12.0400

G-12.0401  New Synod is the unit of the church's life and mission, which consists of not fewer than three presbyteries, which are admitted into New Synod as, provided by this Section.   New Synod is the intermediate government unit responsible for the mission of the church throughout its presbyteries.  New Synod has the same responsibilities and powers of all other synods with the additional responsiblities and powers set forth in this Section.

G-12.0402  New Synod has the responsiblity and power to maintain the standards for ordination and continuing ministry as set forth below.  The standards for ordination, installation, and continuing ministry set forth in this Section shall be binding upon all presbyteries, sessions, and officers of New Synod.  All those called to office within New Synod are to lead a life and engage in ministry in conformity with these standards and the governing bodies of New Synod shall examine qualifications for ordination and installation of officers based on adherence to these standards.  These standards shall be strictly interpreted, followed, and enforced in any judicial process involving New Synod or a governing body or ordained leader within New Synod. 

a.  New Synod and its constituent presbyteries will structure themselves to facilitate the missional identity of their congregations.  Although there are numerous ways to give expression to a missional intent, the congregations of New Synod will emphasize:

-the singular saving work of Jesus Christ,

-the unique and authoritative witness of scripture,

-the calling to live not for themselves and institutional interests, but for others by engaging in loving service locally and beyond,

-international efforts to learn from others within the global church, build relationships, and partner in various ministry endeavors.

b.  The presbyteries and sessions of New Synod will conduct examinations of candidates for church office in a way that preserves the integrity of our common ordination vow:  Do you sincerely receive and adopt the essential tenets of the Reformed faith as expressed in the confessions of our church as authentic and reliable expositions of what Scripture leads us to believe and do you, and will you be instructed and led by those confessions as you lead the people of God?  (W-4.4003).  To that end New Synod will offer its presbyteries and congregations the use of a statement regarding "essential tenents" to assist them in their examination.  While the statement will not purport to identify the essential tenets, it will emphasize several areas of doctrine that must not be overlooked in any such examination.  If the examining body is to assure that a particular candidate does indeed affirm the essential tenents of the Reformed faith, then he or she must be able to affirm these important doctrines.  New Synod will compose its statement for that purpose.  It may be guided by previous efforts, such as the "Essential Tenets and Reformed Distinctives" tool adopted by the Presbytery of San Diego in 2003.  New Synod will also offer this statement to its congregations for the purpose of education and discipleship of members. 

c.  The presbyteries and sessions of New Synod will also use the following statement to examine candidates for church office with regard to their manner of life:  Along with the broader constitutional standards for manner of life (e.g. G-6.0106a), New Synod also holds to the standard that its officers will live either in fidelity within the covenant of marriage bewteen a man and a woman, or chastity in singleness.  Those who cannot make this affirmation for their manner of life will not be approved for ordination or installation in an office, or for membership in a presbytery.  While this standard is certainly not the most important manner of life for one who would serve as an officer in the church, it is an area that has been contested in the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.).  For the sake of clarity in its standards, and consistency in its various governing bodies, this New Synod expects that all of its officers will be able to make this affirmation about their own manner of life.

d.  Congregations and Ministers of the Word and Sacrament within New Synod will celebrate marriages only between a man and woman.  They will not celebrate marriages between members of the same sex in those states whose laws allow such marriages, nor will they celebrate marriage-like unions between members of the same sex. 

e.  Congregations of New Synod, in welcoming all God's children with the unconditional love of Jesus Christ, will also endeavor to teach biblical sexual ethics according to the traditional understandings (i.e. fidelity in marriage between a man and woman, and chastity in singleness).  In this as in all areas of church teaching and discipleship, Christ's forgiveness, redemption, and healing shall be emphasized.

f.  Presbyteries and congregations within New Synod will give deacons, elders, and Ministers of the Word and Sacrament regular opportunities to renew their ordination vows and reaffirm these additional standards.

G-12.0403  After the first meeting of New Synod, any presbytery shall have the right to transfer into or out of New Synod.   A presbytery may request to transfer its synod membership by a two-thirds vote of the presbytery at a regularly called meeting.  The change in membership shall become effective upon the vote of the receiving synod to accept the presbytery into its membership.

G-12.0404  Any presbytery that becomes a part of New Synod will consist of its member churches and Ministers of the Word and Sacrament on the date it becomes a member of New Synod.  New Synod has the power to determine the geographical boundaries of its presbyteries without the need for approval from General Assembly.  The presbyteries of New Synod will have boundaries that overlap with the presbyteries of other synods.  A minister called by a church within a particular presbytery shall be a member of the calling presbytery and permission of any other presbytery with which it has overlapping boundaries shall not be needed to issue the call.  The calling presbytery shall have the right to permit a minister to labor within the geographical boundaries of both without the consent of the other presbytery. 

G-12.0405  A congregation shall have the right to vote on dismissal to a presbytery not in New Synod at a duly called congregational meeting.  Such dismissal, with real property and all other property, shall be effective upon the vote of the receiving presbytery to accept the church into its membership.

G-12.0406  A congregation shall have the right to vote on dismissal to a presbytery within New Synod at a duly called congregational meeting.  Such dismissal, with real property and all other property, shall be effective upon the vote by the receiving presbytery to accept the church into its membership.

G-12.0407  The provisions of this section G-12.0400 supercede and control any other provisions of the Book of Order to the contrary.

G-12.0408  The provisions of this section G-12.0400 may not be amended without the consent of New Synod.  A majority vote of each of its presbyteries is required to give this consent.

G-12.0409  Within 180 days of the vote of the General Assembly to send this amendment to the presbyteries for consideration, any presbytery shall have the right to become one of the originating presbyteries of New Synod by a two-thirds vote of its members.  The creation of New Synod authorized by this Section shall become effective upon the convening of its first meeting, which may be called, by any of the originating presbyteries after the effective date of this amendment.  When New Synod meets it shall be composed of commissioners elected by its presbyteries.  The ratio of commissioners to members at a New Synod meeting shall be the same as for General Assembly.  At the first meeting, a majority vote of the commissioners is required to confirm each of the originating presbyteries as members.  If an originating presbytery does not receive a majority note it shall remain a member of its current geographic synod. 

G-12.0410  At the first meeting of New Synod, the commissioners will adopt a name for New Synod and advise the Office of General Assembly.  Upon receipt of written notice by the Office of General Assembly, all references within the Book of Order, as amended, to the "new synod" shall reflect this change.                                                                                                                                     

 


Comments:  Since Robert Austell was given some vague, non-binding, hope by the General Assembly with respect to Synods, I have left this on the website.     

There are a few issues that need to be resolved with the New Synod structure.  First of all, this amendment may need two New Synods, one for the Evangelical congregations and one for the Progressive congregations. Since this proposal uses existing presbyteries, the Progressive Congregations must be given, not only an opportunity to move, but also a place to move to, which is why two New Synods (one Evangelical and one Progressive), both using non or semi-geographic presbyteries, may be needed.  This will give Progressive congregations and Evangelical congregations an opportunity to move to a like minded Presbytery.  However, the creation of new Presbyteries within the "New Synod"  instead of using existing Presbyteries would solve this issue.  The amendment should also limit the jurisdiction of the General Assembly PJC to adjudicate issues and cases that would affect and impact congregations and Presbyteries within the New Synod, e.g. issues involving ordination standards, marriage standards, church planting, educational materials used, evangelism methods used, etc..  The General Assembly PJC should have no jurisdiction to adjudicate these issues to the extent they apply to congregations and Presbyteries within the "New Synod".